Key takeaways

  • Contingency is pay-on-hire but often favors speed and volume.
  • Retained buys commitment but requires upfront payments, even without a hire.
  • Startups can look for models that combine commitment with pay-on-hire terms and lower fees.

Founders who decide to use a recruiter quickly meet two models: contingency and retained. Each has trade-offs worth understanding before you sign.

Contingency recruiting

You pay only when you hire the recruiter's candidate, typically 25 to 30 percent of first-year salary. Because several agencies may work the same role, the incentive is to send candidates fast, which can mean more resumes and less vetting.

Retained search

The firm is paid in installments, usually starting at kickoff, often 25 to 35 percent in total. You get a dedicated search, but you carry the cost even if the search does not end in a hire. It is common for executive roles.

What startups usually need

Commitment and rigor, without paying before results and without fees designed for large companies. That is why we built tailored startup and small-business plans: a dedicated, rigorous search, nothing upfront on direct-hire searches, and fees up to 50 percent below traditional recruiters.