Key takeaways
- Retained and contingency fees typically run 25 to 35 percent of first-year compensation.
- Ask whether the fee applies to base salary or total compensation; the difference is material.
- Lower fees should not mean lower rigor: insist on a written brief, a short list and a guarantee.
Most executive search firms charge a percentage of the hire's first-year compensation, typically 25 to 35 percent. Contingency agencies usually charge 25 to 30 percent for senior professional roles. For a startup or a small business, that can be the single largest cost of a hire.
How the math works
Take a CTO with a $250,000 base salary. At 25 percent, the search fee is $62,500. At 33 percent, it is $82,500. If first-year compensation includes a target bonus, many contracts calculate the fee on the total, which pushes it higher still.
With Signal Crest you save up to 50 percent of that fee, for the same rigor. On the same $250,000 salary, that can mean keeping more than $40,000 in your budget.
Base salary or total compensation?
A fee calculated on total compensation rises with every bonus and signing payment, so ask what the percentage applies to. We calculate ours on base salary only, and we tell you honestly when a candidate's expectations are out of line or when a lower offer is likely to be accepted.
What should stay the same
Price should not change rigor. Whatever you pay, expect a written brief agreed before outreach starts, a short list of candidates the firm would personally back, structured references, and a replacement guarantee.
Questions to ask any firm
- Is the fee calculated on base salary or total compensation?
- When is each payment due, and is any of it owed if you do not hire?
- How many candidates will you present, and how are they vetted?
- What does the guarantee cover, and for how long?
- Who will actually run the search day to day?
For startups and small businesses, also ask whether the firm will tailor terms to your stage. We do: startups get a plan built around their budget and hiring plan.